Home/Case Law/THEMAS CARMODY vs. CITY OF SAN DIEGO POLICE DEPARTMENT
Regular DecisionReconsideration

THEMAS CARMODY vs. CITY OF SAN DIEGO POLICE DEPARTMENT

Filed: Jan 21, 2011
San Francisco
ADJ3526973 (SDO 0315558) ADJ2783481 (SDO 0355255)

CompFox AI Summary

The Workers' Compensation Appeals Board reversed a WCJ's decision finding no industrial injury to the applicant's heart and hypertension. The Board found that the Agreed Medical Evaluator's initial reports strongly supported industrial causation for hypertension and heart trouble, triggering the Labor Code section 3212.5 presumption. The Board held the AME's subsequent deposition testimony, which reversed his opinion without adequate explanation and rejected the legislative premise of stress-induced heart disease, was insufficient to rebut the presumption. Consequently, both the applicant's heart/hypertension claim and a previously decided claim for lung and hernia injuries were returned to the trial level for benefit determination.

Full Decision Text1 Pages

The Workers' Compensation Appeals Board reversed a WCJ's decision finding no industrial injury to the applicant's heart and hypertension. The Board found that the Agreed Medical Evaluator's initial reports strongly supported industrial causation for hypertension and heart trouble, triggering the Labor Code section 3212.5 presumption. The Board held the AME's subsequent deposition testimony, which reversed his opinion without adequate explanation and rejected the legislative premise of stress-induced heart disease, was insufficient to rebut the presumption. Consequently, both the applicant's heart/hypertension claim and a previously decided claim for lung and hernia injuries were returned to the trial level for benefit determination.

Read the full decision

Join + legal professionals. Create a free account to access the complete text of this decision and search our entire database.

Ready to streamline your practice?

Apply these legal strategies instantly. CompFox helps you find decisions, analyze reports, and draft pleadings in minutes.

THEMAS CARMODY vs. CITY OF SAN DIEGO POLICE DEPARTMENT (2011) – San Francisco | CompFox