Marvin Rogers vs. American Medical Response, ACE American Insurance Company

This case concerns a workers' compensation insurer seeking credit for overpaid temporary disability benefits. The applicant, Marvin Rogers, sustained a lumbar spine injury as a paramedic. The insurer paid temporary disability benefits beyond the applicant's permanent and stationary date, but sought credit at the full overpaid amount against permanent disability indemnity. The Appeals Board denied the defendant's petition for reconsideration, upholding the administrative law judge's decision to allow credit only at the lower permanent disability indemnity rate. This denial was based on equitable principles and the fact that the applicant did not act in bad faith, preventing prejudice to the injured worker.