Home/Case Law/JOSE PENALOZA VALDEZ vs. MANUEL AVILA, TRANSGUARD INSURANCE, Administered By FRYE CLAIMS CONSULTATION
Regular DecisionReconsideration

JOSE PENALOZA VALDEZ vs. MANUEL AVILA, TRANSGUARD INSURANCE, Administered By FRYE CLAIMS CONSULTATION

Filed: Oct 28, 2011
San Francisco
ADJ3103905

CompFox AI Summary

This case concerns an applicant awarded 68% permanent disability, including a significant portion for psyche injury, based on a psychologist's report. The defendant appeals, arguing the psychologist's report was improperly admitted and they were denied the opportunity for rebuttal. The Appeals Board rescinded the award, finding that while the report was admissible, the defendant should have been allowed to obtain a rebuttal report, especially since the psychologist was not the primary treating physician. The case is returned for further proceedings to develop the record regarding the psyche injury and disability claims.

Full Decision Text1 Pages

This case concerns an applicant awarded 68% permanent disability, including a significant portion for psyche injury, based on a psychologist's report. The defendant appeals, arguing the psychologist's report was improperly admitted and they were denied the opportunity for rebuttal. The Appeals Board rescinded the award, finding that while the report was admissible, the defendant should have been allowed to obtain a rebuttal report, especially since the psychologist was not the primary treating physician. The case is returned for further proceedings to develop the record regarding the psyche injury and disability claims.

Read the full decision

Join + legal professionals. Create a free account to access the complete text of this decision and search our entire database.

Ready to streamline your practice?

Apply these legal strategies instantly. CompFox helps you find decisions, analyze reports, and draft pleadings in minutes.

JOSE PENALOZA VALDEZ vs. MANUEL AVILA, TRANSGUARD INSURANCE, Administered By FRYE CLAIMS CONSULTATION (2011) – San Francisco | CompFox