Home/Case Law/JAIME VILLANUEVA vs. DALEY'S DRYWALL & TAPING, INC.; ARCH INSURANCE
Regular DecisionDecision After Reconsideration

JAIME VILLANUEVA vs. DALEY'S DRYWALL & TAPING, INC.; ARCH INSURANCE

Filed: Sep 12, 2025
Oakland
ADJ14216452

CompFox AI Summary

Applicant Jaime Villanueva sought reconsideration of a June 16, 2025 decision that found 0% permanent disability based on a Qualified Medical Examiner's report. The Appeals Board found the QME's report by Dr. Bruce Huffer to be unsubstantial due to its conclusory nature, lack of reasoning, and failure to discuss pertinent medical records from other physicians. Consequently, the Board granted the petition, rescinded the original decision, and returned the matter for further proceedings to properly develop the medical record regarding the applicant's lumbar spine injury and claimed radiculopathy.

Full Decision Text1 Pages

Applicant Jaime Villanueva sought reconsideration of a June 16, 2025 decision that found 0% permanent disability based on a Qualified Medical Examiner's report. The Appeals Board found the QME's report by Dr. Bruce Huffer to be unsubstantial due to its conclusory nature, lack of reasoning, and failure to discuss pertinent medical records from other physicians. Consequently, the Board granted the petition, rescinded the original decision, and returned the matter for further proceedings to properly develop the medical record regarding the applicant's lumbar spine injury and claimed radiculopathy.

Read the full decision

Join + legal professionals. Create a free account to access the complete text of this decision and search our entire database.

Ready to streamline your practice?

Apply these legal strategies instantly. CompFox helps you find decisions, analyze reports, and draft pleadings in minutes.

JAIME VILLANUEVA vs. DALEY'S DRYWALL & TAPING, INC.; ARCH INSURANCE (2025) – Oakland | CompFox