Home/Case Law/ALFONSO SOLORIO vs. AJ CARVALHO AND SONS, BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY SAN DIEGO
Regular DecisionWorkers' Compensation

ALFONSO SOLORIO vs. AJ CARVALHO AND SONS, BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY SAN DIEGO

Filed: Dec 27, 2010
San Francisco
ADJ6436701; ADJ6436674

CompFox AI Summary

Applicant sought removal to rescind an order taking the case off-calendar for further discovery after a mandatory settlement conference. The Appeals Board denied removal, agreeing with the WCJ that further record development was warranted due to an Agreed Medical Evaluator's report lacking clarity regarding permanent disability ratings under different guidelines. The majority found no prejudice to the applicant in allowing this development. Commissioner Caplane dissented, arguing that discovery should not be reopened post-settlement conference without a proper showing of deficiency, especially before trial.

Full Decision Text1 Pages

Applicant sought removal to rescind an order taking the case off-calendar for further discovery after a mandatory settlement conference. The Appeals Board denied removal, agreeing with the WCJ that further record development was warranted due to an Agreed Medical Evaluator's report lacking clarity regarding permanent disability ratings under different guidelines. The majority found no prejudice to the applicant in allowing this development. Commissioner Caplane dissented, arguing that discovery should not be reopened post-settlement conference without a proper showing of deficiency, especially before trial.

Read the full decision

Join + legal professionals. Create a free account to access the complete text of this decision and search our entire database.

Ready to streamline your practice?

Apply these legal strategies instantly. CompFox helps you find decisions, analyze reports, and draft pleadings in minutes.

ALFONSO SOLORIO vs. AJ CARVALHO AND SONS, BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY SAN DIEGO (2010) – San Francisco | CompFox