Cbc Framing, Inc.; Arch Insurance Company. Ab Gallagher Bassett, Horacio Montoya, WORKERS’ COMPENSATION APPEALS BOARDSTATE OF CALIFORNIAHORACIO MONTOYA,Applicant,vs.CBC FRAMING, INC.; ARCH INSURANCE COMPANY. AB GALLAGHER BASSETT,Defendants.Case No. ADJ8518632(Sacramento District Office)OPINION AND ORDER GRANTING PETITION FOR REMOVAL AND NOTICE OF INTENTION TO ADMIT EVIDENCE Defendant seeks removal of the January 11, 2017 Minute Order, wherein the workers’ compensation administrative law judge (WCJ) ordered defendant to provide a Functional Capacity Evaluation for applicant. Applicant alleged that, while employed as a carpenter on August 24, 2012, he sustained an industrial injury to his head, eye including optic nerve, brain, psyche (in the form of stress), and ear (internal). Defendant contends that the WCJ’s Minute Order will cause it to suffer significant prejudice and irreparable harm. We have considered the Petition for Removal (Petition) and applicant’s Answer, and we have reviewed the record in this matter. The WCJ prepared a Report and Recommendation on Petition for Removal (Report), recommending that the Petition be denied. For the reasons discussed below, we will grant defendant’s Petition. Removal of a case to the WCAB “is an extraordinary remedy, rarely exercised[.]” (Castro v. Workers’ Comp. Appeals Bd. (1996) 61 Cal.Comp.Cases 1460, 1462 (writ den.).) The party seeking removal must show that the order it appeals “will result in significant prejudice [or] … irreparable harm.” (Cal. Code Regs., tit. 8, § 10843.) A WCJ’s decision must be “based on admitted evidence in the record. Such evidence may include: the recorded admissions and stipulations of the parties; the testimony of witnesses, if any; and , documentary evidence including admitted medical records and physicians’ reports (Cal. Code Regs., tit. 8, § 10626), permanent disability evaluation reports (Cal. Code Regs., tit. 8, § 1
Horacio Montoya, vs. Cbc Framing, Inc.; Arch Insurance Company. Ab Gallagher Bassett,
In this case, the Workers' Compensation Appeals Board granted the defendant's Petition for Removal of the January 11, 2017 Minute Order, which ordered the defendant to provide a Functional Capacity Evaluation for the applicant. The Board found that the WCJ's Minute Order did not provide an adequate and completely developed record, and that the defendant would suffer significant prejudice and irreparable harm if the order was not removed. The Board issued a 15-day Notice of Intention to admit the Panel Qualified Medical Evaluation in Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery submitted by Douglas H. L. Chin, M.D., dated September 16, 2016, into evidence for the limited purpose of determining the defendant's Petition for Removal.
- Filed On:
- Court: California, Sacramento
- Case No. ADJ8518632
To continue reading ... start a FREE Trial for 10 days
Discover the cases you didn’t know you were missing!
Copyright © 2023 - CompFox Inc.